I was one of those people who downloaded songs from Napster with wild abandon. It wasn’t until Napster was shut down, and the artists began speaking up about ‘stealing music’ that it even occurred to me that I was doing anything wrong. Logically, it’s as clear as day. I think I was just swept away by the unprecedented access to bunches of music in digital form, that I had on records, sitting growing dust bunnies in the closet. To be able to listen to that stuff again made me really happy. And, for the most part, the stuff I downloaded I *had* paid for, just on records and tapes. To have to pay for it again, in retrospect, wouldn’t have made me happy if I’d thought of it, which of course I didn’t.
A few months ago, I didn’t know what a ‘torrent’ was. When it was introduced to me, I immediately searched for a song I’d been looking for on ITunes for years, and couldn’t find anywhere, because it hadn’t been released for download in the US. I found it. I was very excited. Then I started to think bigger, about how much music I still owned that I couldn’t play because it was on tapes or records. Then I started thinking about music that I wanted that I hadn’t bought yet. Then I realized that you could download movies with torrents free (the kind that shows up in unmarked wrappers).
My mind didn’t make these jumps by itself, they were shown to me by googling and visiting sites that allow you to download torrents (and the Trojans that are attached to them).
My mind became totally blown when I realized that I could download the entire Rosetta Stone system that my parents paid over $500 for, so that Aidan could learn Japanese. He’s also trying to decide whether to take Mandarin Chinese or Latin next year, and Gillian is studying Spanish. All these things are available for free online. Is it legal? Obviously not. Is it ethical? Nope. Would it be an incredibly helpful tool for my children that would enhance their studies in school? You bet. This has all led to many questions that I’ve been pondering over the last week or so.
Aside from the obvious ethical issues, how is this being done so readily and out-in-the-open if it’s illegal?
As far as the ethical issues are concerned, my friend Amy helped me a while back with wrapping my brain around stuff like this. If I can’t afford it, I should save up for it if it’s important enough for me. It’s all about choice. My rationalization to that is that we have no savings account (again, spending beyond our means in the past was a choice, even if it wasn’t done purposefully), and we’re struggling to make our bills every month (again, a choice, although my psychiatrist told me I had no business even thinking about work while unmedicated, which I was until last summer. I’ve started the process of taking over my father’s business – he’s slowly retiring – and our money situation should eventually begin to ease).
I really can’t find a way to rationalize doing something like downloading several thousand dollars worth of software without paying for it, while following the Wiccan Ethics Hierarchy by which I live. I certainly wouldn’t be able to explain to my children how this would be okay to do.
So why am I still tempted?












